Who would win Dooku against Darth Malgus?


View Full Version: Arenathread - This is where fighting is going on



Surely one or the other already knows this from other forums:
You say a fight between any 2 characters (also groups if you like, but preferably 1: 1) and the next one then says who wins and why.
Please plausible reasons, no meaningless one-liners.
I can also post a description of how the fight could have gone.
The one who gives reasons first can then of course announce the next fight.
So let's go, Sora Bulq versus Darth Maul.

Well, say although I'm not really his fan
Darth Maul.

Anyone who can kill Qui-Gon Jinn and almost killed his student can kill any other Jedi except most council members .;)
In addition, double blade is technically better than simple, as you saw in episode I very nicely .;)

Ok, the explanation is fine.
So go ahead, announce the next battle;)

Dooku VS Grievous

Could be interesting .;)

Could be a tough fight.
Would tend to docu because he's actually a good fighter. Grievious, on the other hand, has his 4 lightsabers: D
But yes, I would say documentary because he is simply the better fighter. Can't explain that exactly but a Jedi / Sith fights better than a cyborg.

If you don't announce the next fight I'll take care of it ...
Hope that doesn't speak against the rules.

Asajj Ventress vs. Ahsoka Tano: gratz

Oh, should I announce the next one right away? Oops: D

Well, definitely Ventress because Ahsoka just lacks the experience and Ventress is a trained Sith assassin. Was there a fight between the two of them in one episode of The Clone Wars, right? I just don't know who won, even believe that Ahsoka fled ^^


Darth Bane versus Zannah

Clearly Darth Bane, he has more experience and I guess he also has the higher power :)

Young (bad) Anakin vs. Lord Vader


Well, definitely Ventress because Ahsoka just lacks the experience and Ventress is a trained Sith assassin. Was there a fight between the two of them in one episode of The Clone Wars, right? I just don't know who won, even believe that Ahsoka fled ^^

Yes, but because she had to return to the captured viceroy or something ...: dnuhr:

Well, Anakin, of course, he would have become the most powerful Sith without his mutilation, the armor ultimately hindered him.

Darth Wyyrlok vs. Darth Malak

Draw. On the one hand, Malak is a mighty, vigorous fighter who also has considerable skill in handling the Force, on the other hand, Wyyrlok is ... exactly the same. : D

Vandar Tokare vs. Master Yoda

Oh please.
I wanted to prevent something like that.
No, I don't accept this explanation, you can clap that everywhere, try a little more.

(Of course, someone else can now provide a better explanation and then it's your turn)

Oh please.
I wanted to prevent something like that.
No, I don't accept this explanation, you can clap that everywhere, try a little more.

(Of course, someone else can now provide a better explanation and then it's your turn)

Well why not?
Not every fight has to end with a winner, as it was already in Star Wars, see Dooku VS Yoda.
The Count finally withdrew, on the one hand, of course, because he hardly had a chance against Yoda and on the other hand because he wanted to withdraw anyway.
I would also be interested in whether he would have done better if Anakin and Obi-Wan hadn't been there first ...

Well and Palpatine VS Yoda would be such a duel too.

A duel would only be won for me if one duelist disarms the other, can capture him or kill him .;)

For me it's not about the draw, it's about that


On the one hand, Malak is a mighty, vigorous fighter who also has considerable skill in handling the Force, on the other hand, Wyyrlok is ... exactly the same.

That's not an explanation

Well, Anakin, of course, he would have become the most powerful Sith without his mutilation, the armor ultimately hindered him.

On the other hand, you have to see that Darth Vader is MUCH more experienced in power than the bad Anakin.
But good: D


Darth Wyyrlok vs. Darth Malak
I think Darth Malak is marginally superior to Wyyrlok and, in case of doubt, would probably win.

Next duel:
Jango Fett vs. Boba Fett

I think Boba would beat up his "father" quite a bit because he has the better equipment than Jango because he has his heyday after the Clone Wars and now there are better rifles, rockets and jetpacks, etc. In terms of skills, however, I would consider them to be pretty much on par with the equipment

Next duel: Darth Revan vs Darth Sidious

Sidious, because he has no scruples, Revan has finally returned to the bright side, Sidious would certainly be willing to sacrifice a lot to destroy him.

And in order not to treat yogurt unfairly:
I don't think you can say anything about Vandar vs Yoda because you never saw Vandar fight.

Darth Sion vs Durge (Duel of the Eternal)

Definitely Darth Sion because he would be superior with his enormous power.

Master Plo Koon vs. Aayla Secura ...

I mahc times on before the thread dies: o
I think Plo Koon should be the winner here, he is older and more experienced, and therefore probably stronger in power.
But I don't think you can judge who wins in a sword fight, you haven't seen Plo fight enough for that.

Cad Bane vs. Dengar

I'll keep going .. ^^

Well, I tend to prefer Cad Bane, which in my opinion is more experienced and better equipped. In the CW series he also beats Jedi with inventive tricks etc .; guess he'd win.

Uthar Wynn vs. Yuthura Bane (Both without Revan's help: D)

I think Uthar should definitely be the winner.
If Yuthura could have made it without Revan, she would not have asked him for help, Uthar is simply the older and more experienced in power, without these ambush tactics she would certainly have been killed.

Sometimes a team duel (but shouldn't become the rule, please) Darth Revan and Darth Malak against Darth Nihilus and Darth Sion.

I think that Darth Nihilus and Darth Sion would win, thanks to Sion's enormous power potential and of course not least thanks to Nihilus' unique ability ^^

Boba Fett vs. Cad Bane

I think Boba Fett would win because if you look at the bigger picture he's better equipped.

Cody vs Rex

Cody, he has a much higher rank, ergo the greater experience, and he is more tactical and sensible (like Obi-Wan) Rex is more of the hot-headed type (like Anakin).

Atton Rand vs. Carth Onasi

Somehow I always hear the same reasons here. All deviations from "He wins because he is better". I mean these are not justifications, you have to be more precise, otherwise such a thread makes no sense.

Somehow I always hear the same reasons here. All deviations from "He wins because he is better". I mean these are not justifications, you have to be more precise, otherwise such a thread makes no sense.

I actually wanted to do it like that at the beginning, but apparently nobody wants to do it: dnuhr:

Well, let's try again

So that this doesn't go down completely

I think Atton would win because he has no qualms about killing someone and, for example, he can easily take on Jedis. I also see Atton as being more devious and cunning.

Darth Maul vs Darth Thyranus

Here I would clearly see Darth Maul as the winner.
Darth Maul is more athletic, more hateful, faster etc than the Count.
At least in sword fighting, I don't know what it looks like in the use of power.
However, I take as an argument that Darth Maul was able to defeat Darth Vader in direct combat, which in turn was stronger than the count.

Visas Marr versus Juhani.

Phew, if it were allowed I would say patted. I know Juhanni from the game, but Visar Marr doesn't. Jedipedia didn't really make me smarter either, apart from the fact that she changes sides just like Juhanni. It doesn't seem to be really "powerful".

That's why I would say Juhanni wins, because I can judge her abilities better than the other one.

Yes, I know wonderfully creative.

i'm creative and propose a fight between darth bane and starkiller, pretty much the most powerful power users in star war history.

i'm creative and propose a fight between darth bane and starkiller, pretty much the most powerful power users in star war history.

One of the most powerful Sith Lords of all time against the ridiculously overpowered wannabe sith who, although just an insignificant insertable character, defeats Vader and makes the Emperor sweat ...

Despite my disdain for Starkiller (the name alone sounds like kiddy junk :( (yes, I know, it's just his alias)) I stay objective and tend to draw.

Darth Bane undoubtedly has more experience and greater physical strength, but Starkiller has a great power potential ...

In the end it would either end with a lucky strike or one of the two would be careless for a moment. Or Starkiller could throw Star Destroyers: o. Or but Darth Bane would try to explain to Starkiller why one of them made a journey through time, and Starkiller's brain would become burst.

But I digress.

From a subjective point of view, I would say that Darth Bane would land the lucky strike, as Starkiller would tend to be more careless (and at TFU the fights were over so quickly that you cannot tell whether S. would hold out a long duel).

Next fight: Exar Kun against Count Dooku

Another time travel §ugly

So I think Exar Kun would win. He has powers that Dooku can never achieve. He is much more adept in the teachings of the Sith and also - I suspect - physically superior as the inventor of the double blade. In addition, Dooku was quite old when he became a Sith.
So I think either Exar Kun kills Dooku, or - more likely - Dooku flees. Whether he succeeds is something else.

Next fight: General Grievous against Asajj Ventress

The fight has already existed, even Grievous against Ventress AND Durge, Grievous has won big .....

Darth Nihilus versus the Emperor and Darth Vader.

Do you now think that Vader and Palpatine fight as a team or everyone against everyone? ^^
Well, I'll assume the former. :)
I believe that the Emperor and Vader would win even if, in my opinion, Nihilus would win in individual duels: o
The reasoning:
I believe that Nihilus is slightly superior to the Emperor in terms of power, but Vader could easily distract him with a few strokes of the lightsaber and once the two have the upper hand, Nihilus can say goodbye to the world ^ - ^.

Next fight:
THE HK-47 versus A HK-50 ^ - ^
if your programming would allow it: o

Hmmm, difficult in principle, because the HK-50 was already very similar to the HK-47. If the HK-50 had an ion bolt launcher, which they were often equipped with, the duel would be over. If not, I'd say these potential killer droids would have shot each other until one fell over. I would tend to HK-50 because it was built later and would probably also have newer set-up technology. So much for that .;)

Yoda vs. Darth Sion

hui! just not all at once ^ - ^
well then i'll say that yoda would win because he has more honorary experience
I also believe that he can handle the lightsaber better and that he is the stronger power user
probably sion couldn't deal with yoda as an opponent at all: D
too small:>
EDIT:
um yes so next fight:>:
mace windu vs. malak

Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.2 Copyright © 2021 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.